The Continuation of Confidence Meets Caution: Navigating a Two-Speed Hiring Market

By Jacob Thomas Associates Ltd – ISO 9001:2015 Accredited Experts in Industrial & Manufacturing Recruitment


Intro

In last month’s UK Labour Market Tracker – August 2025, we explored how optimism was returning to UK boardrooms — with businesses forecasting growth, exploring automation, and investing in product development — yet permanent hiring was still dragging behind.

This month’s findings confirm much of what we reported then: confidence is continuing to build, but hiring activity still hasn’t caught up. In fact, the gap between sentiment and action has widened.

For readers who have been following since our June 2025 Manufacturing & Jobs Outlook, this reinforces the two-speed market we’ve been tracking for months — where strong business confidence contrasts with ongoing caution in recruitment.


The Numbers in Brief

  • Permanent placements: Fell sharply in July — Index 40.0 (well below the 50.0 no-change mark)
  • Temporary billings: Declined at the fastest pace in six months — Index 44.6
  • Vacancies: Total Vacancies Index 43.2 — down for the 21st consecutive month
  • Candidate supply: Elevated for both perm and temp roles — among the highest levels since late 2020
  • Pay growth: Slowest rise in permanent starter salaries in over four years

Reading Between the Lines

1. Confidence without commitment
We said it last month, and it still holds true: while business surveys like the UK Business Outlook June 2025: A Two-Speed Market show rising optimism, actual hiring behaviour suggests many firms are waiting for more certainty before making long-term commitments.

2. Candidate-rich market
As in July’s report, redundancies and reduced hiring earlier in the year continue to feed a surge in available talent. Employers now face an unusual challenge — not finding candidates, but identifying the right ones in a larger, more varied pool.

3. Sector nuances
Engineering and construction — sectors we noted in our July analysis as relatively resilient — still show better-than-average performance, particularly in temp hiring. Retail and hospitality remain weaker, reflecting ongoing consumer caution.

4. Wage pressures easing
Just as we observed last month, slowing pay growth is easing cost pressures for employers, though niche skills still command premium rates. This is still a rare moment where high talent availability coincides with controlled salary inflation.

5. Flexibility as a theme
July’s temporary hiring slowdown mirrors the overall cooling trend, but the strategic use of contingent labour remains a key lever for businesses — something we’ve consistently flagged in earlier updates as vital for operational agility.


Regional Trends: Not All Areas Are Equal

  • Midlands: Temporary demand is holding up better than the national average, particularly in logistics and light manufacturing — echoing patterns we identified in last month’s Tracker.
  • North of England: Candidate supply remains highest, but wage pressures persist in skilled trades and healthcare — a repeat of trends we saw in both June and July.
  • London & South East: Permanent hiring is softer, yet tech and professional services show resilience compared to other regions.
  • Scotland & Wales: Both see elevated candidate supply, but sharper vacancy reductions indicate a more competitive jobs market.

Permanent vs Temporary: The Growing Gap

Last month, we warned of a potential “permanent lag” — where perm hiring only recovers well after confidence indicators turn positive. July’s data strengthens that view. Employers are:

  • Pausing or cancelling long-term hires
  • Redirecting budgets toward short-term, project-based staffing
  • Using temporary contracts as a hedge against uncertainty

Historical Context

The last time we saw this combination of high candidate supply and slower wage growth (late 2020, mid-2021), early movers gained an advantage:

  • Better retention
  • Lower recruitment costs
  • Ready-made talent pipelines

Those who waited paid more once demand picked up — a risk still relevant now.


Longer-term Implications

If this high candidate supply persists into Q4, we could see:

  • Wage inflation remains subdued for most roles
  • More selective, strategic hiring
  • Greater use of temp-to-perm conversions to bridge skill gaps

But if hiring confidence snaps back, the current buyer’s market for talent could reverse quickly — a point we made in July and remains highly relevant.


Looking Ahead

Key markers for the months ahead:

  • Whether confidence can turn into tangible headcount growth
  • Wage movements in shortage occupations
  • The timing of a temp hiring rebound — likely to be the first real sign of wider recovery

Sources & Fair Use:

Analysis based on the KPMG & REC UK Report on Jobs – July 2025 (data collected 12–24 July 2025, compiled by S&P Global) and insights from previous Jacob Thomas Associates releases. All figures are paraphrased for fair commentary and market insight purposes


🔗 UK Labour Market Tracker – August 2025
🔗 UK Business Confidence Update – July 2025
🔗 UK Manufacturing & Jobs Outlook – June 2025